Annual Conference 2027 — Registration now open

Leasehold Interests Up in Smoke: Agency Error and Vested Rights

By Moshe Abtan

November 17, 2026

Leasehold Interests Up in Smoke: Agency Error and Vested Rights

11.17.2026

By Moshe Abtan

A sign on a green building facade featuring the word CANNABIS in large, white, raised letters.
Text on a red background reading: Get a glimpse of the N.Y. Real Property Law Journal with this preview from a current or forthcoming issue. Not a Section member? To learn more about the Real Property Law Section and access additional articles click here to JOIN the Section.

After Conbud CEO Coss Marte spent hundreds of hours navigating New York’s new cannabis regulatory framework, he finally received state approval.[1] He quickly anchored his business with a long-term lease backed by a personal guarantee, making a $420,000 deposit and committing to $38,000 in monthly rent.[2] To meet state mandates, he spent over $1.3 million on a specialized build-out and established an annual payroll of $1.4 million.[3] That entire investment, along with the massive personal liability tied to his guarantee, was at risk after the New York State Office of Cannabis Management declared its required distance measurement standard legally incorrect.[4] This standard establishes the official method for calculating statutory school buffer zones, which the agency wrongly measured door-to-door rather than to the school property line.[5] His experience was not unique – more than 100 New York cannabis entrepreneurs faced the same problem. His story is a harsh lesson in New York real estate and administrative law, showing that when agency approval is wrongfully given, good-faith reliance may offer no protection. In this case, a legislative fix proved to be the only way for these entrepreneurs to prevent substantial financial loss.

Banner for the New York State Bar Association Annual Conference. Registration is open for January 19-22, 2022, at New York Hilton Midtown. Includes a Register Today button and a 150 years anniversary logo.

Rules, Reliance, and Regret

The Office of Cannabis Management and the Cannabis Control Board were tasked with launching New York’s legal cannabis market.[6] Their mission was to rectify past injustices associated with prohibition by establishing a streamlined regulatory framework for the rapidly expanding billion-dollar industry.[7] From the start, the Office of Cannabis Management faced backlash, including constitutional challenges to its social equity licensing structure, repeated lawsuits and rollout delays, highlighting the difficulties of building a trustworthy statewide market.[8]

Building and enforcing this new regulatory system was a massive undertaking. As the primary authority, the office provided guidance and issued determinations for applicants to rely upon. One key rule required dispensaries to be at least 500 feet from school property lines under Cannabis Law Section 72(6)(a).[9] However, from 2023 to mid-2024, the office instructed applicants to use a “door-to-door” measurement system by calculating the distance from the dispensary’s front door to the nearest school’s front door.[10] This measurement strategy was modeled after the existing standards used by the state liquor industry.[11] Thus, all applicants and businesses followed this door-to-door guidance when selecting locations and received state approval based on this standard.

After years of delays and uncertainty, the first round of licenses were issued in late 2022, and shop owners gained confidence in New York’s cannabis market as the regulatory system took shape.[12] Through secured leases, they gathered capital, strengthened community ties, and embarked on the journey toward opening their own dispensaries, all while closely following the state’s guidelines and regulations. However, on July 28, 2025, that confidence collapsed. On that day, the Office of Cannabis Management admitted its door-to-door standard conflicted with state law because a plain reading of the statutes requires dispensaries to be located more than 500 feet from a school property line.[13] Suddenly, this “property line” standard, which the agency deemed correct, meant that over 150 dispensaries were suddenly non-compliant.[14] Gov. Kathy Hochul called the situation “a major screw-up” and acknowledged the severity of the regulatory failure.[15]

Leases and Livelihoods at Risk

This so-called screw-up immediately threatened licensees’ most significant asset: their leases. The Office of Cannabis Management’s letter warned that the measurement correction would lead to the denial of license renewals, effectively declaring their businesses illegal.[16] This put licensees in material breach with their lessors under the lawful use clauses of their commercial leases.[17] For these entrepreneurs, relocation was not an option. Many had already personally spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on specialized buildouts and signed personal guarantees on their leases, leaving them exposed to total financial ruin.[18]

Furthermore, as licensing delays eased, New York’s cannabis market became “constrained by real estate,” turning the search for compliant storefronts into a “needle-in-a-haystack exercise.”[19] Landlords capitalized on this scarcity, demanding premium rents and large deposits, leaving entrepreneurs trapped in expensive leases with nowhere else to go as compliant spaces dried up.

A Flawed Fix and Temporary Court Relief

New York State’s response was a $15 million relief fund, but it only applied to the 44 applicants who had not yet opened their doors.[20] The 108 dispensaries already operating were excluded from the fund and were told by the Office of Cannabis Management they could continue operating without a valid license while lawmakers worked on a legislative fix.[21] For these dispensaries, this did nothing to quell the fear and confusion surrounding the massive shift. Licensees understandably worried that expired licenses would prevent them from getting insurance or banking services, making their businesses vulnerable.[22]

As the uncertainty continued and financial risks grew, a dozen licensees sued the office in Albany County Supreme Court.[23] In Conbud v. New York State Cannabis Control Board, they argued that its reversal was an unlawful, retroactive policy reversal that violated the State Administrative Procedure Act by creating a new rule without a public comment period, and was therefore arbitrary and capricious.[24] Petitioners emphasized that in good-faith reliance on the state’s approvals, they “incurred substantial financial obligations, executed leases, completed architectural designs and in most cases, completed a retail dispensary build-out.”[25]

This reliance created vested rights and property interests now threatened by “retroactive reinterpretation.”[26] This resulted in irreparable harm to many licensees, threatening their businesses and exposing them to personal liability under their lease agreements. Furthermore, the licensees argued that the state’s legally indefensible reinterpretation of its own guidance violated Article 78 standards and impermissibly applied a new substantive rule retroactively.[27]

With no opposition to their motion, the court granted the licensees a temporary victory and issued a preliminary injunction ordering the office to revert to its previously established method of calculating distances for license renewals.[28] This order – which expired on Feb. 15 – required the office to adhere to its door-to-door standard from its prior guidance for renewals, prohibited enforcement of the new property line measurement, and permitted affected shops to remain open in compliance with their leases until statutory relief was enacted.[29]

Vested Rights, Estoppel and Agency Error

Under New York law, vested rights and estoppel define the limits of reliance on government approvals. A vested right may be established when a landowner, acting under a legally issued permit, shows a “commitment to the purpose for which the permit was granted” by making substantial improvements and incurring significant development expenses.[30] By contrast, the doctrine of estoppel is an equitable principle that prevents a party from acting inconsistently where another has relied to their detriment, but it does not create any legal right and cannot legalize conduct that is otherwise unlawful.[31]

When these principles are applied here, the licensees’ reliance appears significant. The shop owners followed the Office of Cannabis Management’s guidance under a new regulatory framework and “invested personal and borrowed funds” based on its express approvals.[32] They spent hundreds of hours and dollars creating goodwill among the communities they wanted to operate in, hired staff and incurred significant construction costs, all while relying on the agency’s framework.[33] The sudden about-face now threatened to send all that investment and community trust up in smoke.[34]

In Parkview Associates v. City of New York, the Court of Appeals addressed the limits of both vested rights and estoppel. In that case, a developer received a permit based on an erroneous interpretation of a zoning map and proceeded with substantial construction before the city discovered the violation of the applicable zoning height restrictions.[35] The developer argued that its extensive reliance on the permit created vested rights and that the city should be estopped from enforcing the law.[36] These claims were rejected when the Court of Appeals held the building permit was invalid when issued, vesting no rights, and that “estoppel may not be invoked against a municipal agency to prevent it from discharging its statutory duties.”[37]

By contrast, the court in Town of Orangetown v. Magee held that a landowner may acquire a legitimate claim of entitlement when, pursuant to a legally issued permit, the project is substantially advanced through improvements and significant expenditures.[38] Once this property interest is acquired, due process protects it from “arbitrary or irrational municipal actions destructive of this interest.”[39] Because the permit was valid when issued, the defendants in Orangetown had a protected vested right to continue construction, despite subsequent zoning changes and improper permit revocation.

The state’s measurement error mirrors Parkview, not Orangetown. The agency admitted that its door-to-door distance rule conflicted with Cannabis Law Section 72(6)(a), meaning the approvals granted were unlawful when issued. Under Parkview, an invalid license creates no vested rights, and estoppel cannot prevent an agency from fulfilling its statutory duties or force it to continue an erroneous implementation.[40] Although the dispensary owners’ reliance and financial losses are severe, the law does not protect reliance on an approval that was erroneous from the start.

A Legislative Lifeline

This legal chaos is exactly why the Conbud injunction was so critical. It was not a final ruling, but a temporary shield designed to give the New York State Legislature time to provide a fix beyond the courts’ reach. That legislative lifeline arrived on Feb. 11 when Gov. Hochul signed into law a bill protecting those licensees and applicants impacted by the school proximity review just four days before the temporary injunction was set to expire.[41] This bill permanently resolved the crisis by codifying the door-to-door measurement standard and grandfathering in licenses and approved locations granted prior to July 28, 2025.[42] Crucially, the statute reinforced this protection by mandating that “[n]o renewal of a license shall be denied because of the restrictions” in the proximity rules.[43] This ensured that these entrepreneurs were no longer trapped in legal limbo due to a state error and allowed them to renew their licenses, keep their doors open, and protect the hard work and capital they had poured into their shops.

The fallout from New York’s cannabis licensing mistake is about more than just lost licenses. It has shaken trust in the rules that businesses and property owners rely on to make substantial investments in an evolving industry. These dispensary owners poured their time, money and hope into their stores, only to face uncertainty and potential ruin when the state changed the rules after the fact. Ultimately, the Legislature provided the statutory fix these entrepreneurs needed to keep their doors open, protect their leases, capital, and livelihoods after months of instability.


Moshe Abtan is a 3L at St. John’s University School of Law. This article appears in a forthcoming issue of the N.Y. Real Property Law Journal, where he also serves on the student editorial board as an articles editor. The N.Y Real Property Law Journal is published by NYSBA’s Real Property Law Section. For more information, please visit nysba.org/rpls.

Endnotes:

[1] Affirmation of Coss Marte ¶¶ 7–13, Conbud v. N.Y. State Cannabis Control Bd., Index No. 908591-25 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. Albany Cnty. Sept. 24, 2025), NYSCEF Doc. No. 6.

[2] Id. ¶ 6.

[3] Id. ¶¶ 32, 46.

[4] Id. ¶¶ 29, 32.

[5] Exhibit B, Letter from Felicia A. B. Reid, Acting Exec. Dir., N.Y. State Off. of Cannabis Mgmt., to Licensees (July 28, 2025), Conbud v. N.Y. State Cannabis Control Bd., Index No. 908591-25 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. Albany Cnty. Sept. 24, 2025), NYSCEF Doc. No. 15.

[6] About the Office of Cannabis Management, N.Y. State Off. of Cannabis Mgmt., https://cannabis.ny.gov/about-0 (last visited Jan. 15, 2026); S.B. 854-A, 2021–2022 Reg. Sess. (N.Y. 2021).

[7] Id.

[8] Ashley Southall, Court Ruling Casts Doubt on New York’s Cannabis Licensing Process, N.Y. Times (Aug. 12, 2025), https://www.nytimes.com/2025/08/12/nyregion/new-york-cannabis-licensing-unconstitutional.html.

[9] N.Y. Cannabis Law § 72(6)(a).

[10] See John Schroyer, Ex-Cannabis Regulators Cry Foul Over Framing of Licensing Error, Crain’s N.Y. Bus. (Aug. 12, 2025), https://www.crainsnewyork.com/cannabis/ex-cannabis-regulators-cry-foul-over-framing-licensing-error [https://archive.ph/20250812120930].

[11] Id.

[12] Id.

[13] Exhibit B, supra note 5.

[14] Schroyer, supra note 10.

[15] Lilah Burke, The Daily Dirt: Half Baked Bureaucracy at State Cannabis Agency, Real Deal (Sept. 20, 2025), https://therealdeal.com/new-york/2025/09/20/the-daily-dirt-half-baked-bureaucracy-at-cannabis-agency/.

[16] Exhibit B, supra note 5.

[17] Tony Lange, 12 New York Cannabis Businesses Sue State Over School Proximity Fiasco, Cannabis Bus. Times (Aug. 18, 2025), https://www.cannabisbusinesstimes.com/us-states/new-york/news/15753242/12-new-york-cannabis-businesses-sue-state-over-school-proximity-fiasco.

[18] Id.

[19] Greg Tannor & Jessica Gerstein, New York’s Cannabis Retail Market Has Entered Its Real Estate Phase, REBusinessOnline (Mar. 24, 2026), https://rebusinessonline.com/new-yorks-cannabis-retail-market-has-entered-its-real-estate-phase/.

[20] Lange, supra note 17.

[21] Id.

[22] Id.

[23] Id.

[24] Verified Petition and Complaint at 2, 16–18, Conbud v. N.Y. State Cannabis Control Bd., Index No. 908591-25 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. Albany Cnty. Sept. 24, 2025), NYSCEF Doc. No. 2.

[25] Id. at 3.

[26] Id.

[27] Id.

[28] Order Granting Preliminary Injunction, Conbud v. N.Y. State Cannabis Control Bd., Index No. 908591-25 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. Albany Cnty. Sept. 24, 2025), NYSCEF Doc. No. 24.

[29] Id.

[30] Town of Orangetown v. Magee, 88 N.Y.2d 41, 47, 643 N.Y.S.2d 21, 24 (1996).

[31] 5 Warren’s Weed New York Real Property § 48.01 (2026).

[32] Verified Petition and Complaint at 2, 8, Conbud v. N.Y. State Cannabis Control Bd., Index No. 908591-25 (N.Y. Sup. Ct. Albany Cty. Sept. 24, 2025) NYSCEF Doc. No. 2.

[33] Id. at 18, 22.

[34] Id. at 2.

[35] Parkview Assocs. v. City of New York, 71 N.Y.2d 274, 280, 525 N.Y.S.2d 176, 177 (1988).

[36] Id. at 280–81.

[37] Id. at 281–82.

[38] Town of Orangetown, 88 N.Y.2d 41, 52, 643 N.Y.S.2d 21, 24 (1996).

[39] Id. at 53.

[40] Parkview Assocs., 71 N.Y.2d at 279.

[41] S.B. 9155, 2025–2026 Reg. Sess. (N.Y. 2025).

[42] Id.

[43] Id.

Related Articles

Six diverse people sitting holding signs
gradient circle (purple) gradient circle (green)

Join NYSBA

My NYSBA Account

My NYSBA Account